When Compassion Narrows

I feel that jolt every time: stepping around someone slumped on the sidewalk, hand out, asking for change, eyes down, trying not to meet mine. The air shifts — shame, guilt, fear, even a flicker of defensive hostility — until one question nags: Am I a good person, or not?

We like to think collapse comes suddenly, like a breakdown or a blow. But often it begins quietly, inside us. A narrowing that feels protective: don’t look too closely, don’t feel too much.

---

The Inner Avalanche

That single encounter sets off a cascade.

Shame: I have what they don’t.
Guilt: I hesitate, or don’t give.
Fear: What if this could be me? What if I enable harm?
Defensive hostility: A flicker of resistance — don’t lean on me, don’t make me responsible.
Identity threat: At the core, the question presses: Am I a good person, or not?

Each layer presses tighter, shrinking bandwidth. Each one makes it harder to see clearly, harder to act freely.

---

Collapse Pathways

When the avalanche hits, two apparent exits appear:

Hostility: push away through judgment and blame. They chose this. They’re dangerous.
Helplessness: withdraw into despair. The problem’s too big. Nothing I do matters.

Hostility feels like strength.
Helplessness feels like honesty.
But both quietly strip away clarity.

---

The Moment Clarity Slips

This is the hinge point. Not the collapse of systems, or the collapse of a life on the street, but the collapse inside us — the instant compassion narrows.

The danger isn’t just the narrowing. It’s that it can harden, unnoticed, into who we become.

And once compassion narrows, the question is unavoidable: will it calcify into reflex, or widen back into connection?

Part II takes us there.

👉 Next up: When Compassion Widens — why reflex isn’t destiny, and what can still break the loop.